You think a small road debris can total your Tesla with a $20,000 battery replacement? The truth might shock you and here’s what a Tesla repair expert really says.
As a body shop owner, Serge has repaired well over 100 Teslas since early 2023, and his experience contradicts some prevailing myths about the fragility of Tesla batteries.
^^ The Myth of the Fragile Tesla Battery
The common belief surrounding Tesla batteries is that they are incredibly fragile and can easily be damaged by minor impacts. However, Serge reveals a different story. Out of 100 repaired Teslas, only 2 required serious HV battery replacements. Most often, the damage was minor and fixable, such as a broken airway nipple that connects to the battery casing. In many cases, even a small impact that damages components doesn't mean the battery has to be replaced.
^^ Insurance Companies and the 'Replace Everything' Approach
Insurance companies often make the automatic choice to replace entire battery assemblies rather than allowing targeted repairs. This decision sends costs skyrocketing for Tesla owners. Serge highlights that even with minor damage, adjustments by insurers often lead to unnecessary replacements that could be avoided. This scenario creates a costly cycle for owners. It’s crucial for potential buyers to understand this aspect before investing in a Tesla.
^^ The Real Durability of Tesla in Collisions
One prevalent misconception about Tesla vehicles is that they are delicate and cannot endure impacts like traditional cars. This is far from accurate. Teslas come with reinforced designs that actually minimize damage during collisions. Their structures include massive crumple zones and rigid passenger cells to better distribute impact forces. As a result, most collisions only cause minor property damage, making repairs relatively straightforward compared to traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles.
^^ EV vs. ICE: Which One is Really More Fragile?
When comparing EVs and ICE vehicles, it’s important to acknowledge that both have weaknesses. While people often think of ICE vehicles as sturdy, minor collisions can wreak havoc. An oil pan can be easily damaged leading to catastrophic engine issues, while a Tesla may sustain minimal damage. To refute the myths around the fragility of electric vehicles, it's essential to assess their performance based on real experiences.
^^ The Future of EV Repairs
As Tesla and other automakers focus on improving the repairability of their vehicles, the landscape of EV repairs is beginning to evolve. Serge's insights illustrate that many repairs that once seemed daunting may not be so complicated after all. Tesla is also developing new battery technologies, making it likely that future models will be even easier to repair.
^^ Share Your Tesla Experience
While sensational headlines about Tesla repairs grab attention, it’s essential to sift through the noise and discover the actual truth behind these narratives. When it comes to EV repairs, being well-informed can help you navigate insurance policies and understand your vehicle’s durability. Have you or someone you know faced a similar repair scenario with a Tesla? Was the repair as traumatic as the media likes to claim? Share your thoughts in the comments below—the automotive community would love to hear your firsthand experiences!
Armen Hareyan is the founder and Editor in Chief of Torque News. He founded TorqueNews.com in 2010, publishing expert news and analysis about the automotive industry. He has more than a decade of expertise in automotive topics with a focus on Tesla and electric vehicles.