Finding the perfect bread and butter pickles can elevate your sandwiches and snacks. In a recent taste test of nine popular brands, one stood out as the favorite!
Picture this: a crisp, sweet, and tangy pickle slice that enhances your burger or dips gracefully into your favorite salad. It’s no surprise that consumers are on the lookout for the best flavors to complement their meals. In our taste test of nine brands of bread and butter pickles, Trader Joe's Organic Sweet Bread & Butter Pickles took the crown for their exceptional taste and crunch.
How We Tested
To find the best bread and butter pickles, our team of editors conducted an organized taste test featuring slices from each jar. Blind tasting ensured no bias from packaging influenced opinions, allowing our testers to focus purely on the flavors. Each pickle slice was evaluated on a scale from 1 to 5, and at the end of the test, editors selected their overall favorites.
The Contenders
- Trader Joe’s Organic Sweet Bread & Butter Pickles
- Mt. Olive Bread & Butter Chips
- Market Pantry Bread & Butter Chips
- Good & Gather Organic Bread & Butter Pickle Chips
- Great Gherkins Sweet Bread & Butter Sliced Pickles
- Publix Bread & Butter Chips
- Vlasic Bread & Butter Chips
- Bubbies Bread & Butter Chips
- Great Value Bread & Butter Chips
How Each Brand Ranked
Mt. Olive Bread & Butter Chips
Testers expressed appreciation for the balance of sweet and sour flavors that Mt. Olive provided. Many noted the thinner chip's excellent crunch and richness in flavor, making it a favorite for several editors.
Market Pantry Bread & Butter Chips
The Market Pantry brand's chips leaned towards the sweeter side, garnering mixed feedback. While some testers adored the nostalgic flavors reminiscent of homemade pickles, others found it a tad too sugary. One editor even shared, "These taste like the kind my grandparents bought when they visited!"
Good & Gather Organic Bread & Butter Pickle Chips
The crunch of Good & Gather pickles won over a portion of testers, although their taste profiles were varied. Some praised them as ideal for sandwich toppings, while others felt they lacked a distinct flavor.
Great Gherkins Sweet Bread & Butter Sliced Pickles
The Great Gherkins brand, known as ALDI’s signature pickles, divided opinions. Some found them overly sweet, while others enjoyed the bold flavors, though a few noted they'd prefer a better crunch.
Trader Joe’s Organic Sweet Bread & Butter Pickles
Winning the taste test, the Trader Joe's pickles received the highest rating due to their unmatched crunch and delightful flavor profile. Commenters remarked on their versatility, making them perfect not just for burgers but also as a standalone snack.
Publix Bread & Butter Chips
The Publix option stood out for its savory flavors. While it didn't win the top spot, multiple testers praised its crunchy texture and significant flavor.
Vlasic Bread & Butter Chips
In contrast to others, Vlasic chips leaned heavily towards savory and sour notes. Testers agreed these were not their favorite, failing to capture the classic sweet and tangy balance.
Bubbies Bread & Butter Chips
Described as somewhat ambiguous in flavor, Bubbies chips generated comments indicating they straddled the line between bread and butter and dill. A few testers would recommend them for snacking rather than sandwiches.
Great Value Bread & Butter Chips
Despite being a familiar name, Walmart's Great Value chips underperformed in the taste test. While one tester noted they'd be enjoyable in a charcuterie setup, overall preferences placed them towards the bottom of the list.
The Winner
Trader Joe’s Organic Sweet Bread & Butter Pickles captured the title with a nearly full point lead in average ratings, solidifying their status as the taste test champion. The unique aspect of unmatched crunchiness combined with a refreshing flavor secured their victory in our eyes.
If you enjoy bread and butter pickles, give Trader Joe's Organic Sweet Bread & Butter Pickles a try. Whether you're adding them to sandwiches, tossing them into salads, or snacking straight from the jar, their great taste is sure to elevate your meals!