Mullica Hill, New Jersey, offers a delightful escape filled with authentic Amish goods and homemade delicacies that are hard to resist.
Nestled in the charming town of Mullica Hill, the Mullica Hill Amish Market at 108 Swedesboro Road is a treasure trove for both locals and travelers. This bustling market, which opened its doors in 2006, is renowned for bringing the rich flavors of Lancaster County to South Jersey. Open from Thursday through Saturday, it provides the perfect setup for a weekend filled with tasty finds and hearty meals.
The moment you step inside the market, you’re enveloped by the tempting aromas of freshly baked goods and sizzling meats. Over 15 vendors offer a stunning variety of homemade treats, ensuring every visit feels like a feast. Among the highlights is Beiler’s Donut & Coffee Shop, where melt-in-your-mouth donuts and handcrafted coffee create a breakfast experience that surpasses any typical commercial chain. Pair their handcrafted donuts with a rich cup of coffee, and you’re set for a perfect morning.
For those craving something heartier, Yoder’s BBQ Pit is a must-visit. Their selection of rotisserie specialties, smoky wings, and indulgent sides will leave you wanting to try everything on the menu. The smell of BBQ wafting through the air is enough to make anyone's mouth water.
Food enthusiasts can discover even more at the market. Dutch Family Fresh Meats provides premium cuts of steak, pork, and sausage, all sourced and prepared with care. This commitment to quality ensures you can bring home the best of what the region has to offer. For fresh produce, Immer Frish Produce showcases a bounty from local farms, including crisp apples, juicy peaches, and colorful vegetables. Their fresh-squeezed juices and smoothies offer a refreshing pick-me-up that complements your shopping experience beautifully.
Cheese lovers will find their paradise at the Dutch Family Cheese Barn, where glass-bottled milk, creamy spreads, and a variety of cheeses await. Don’t miss their delectable cheesecakes, which are a treat you won’t want to leave without. Seafood fans can also indulge at Capt’n Chucky’s Crab Cake Co., where the crab cakes are deliciously crafted and the menu includes other seafood favorites like shrimp and cod.
Experiencing the Mullica Hill Amish Market is about more than just eating; it’s about community and culture. The vendors come from Pennsylvania Dutch Country, sharing their Amish heritage and craftsmanship. The on-site Dienner’s Country Restaurant offers a buffet and menu filled with comfort food classics like roasted beef with gravy and pumpkin pancakes. While some patrons note the buffet can be hit-or-miss, the made-to-order dishes consistently impress. With the restaurant opening at 7 a.m. and the market at 8 a.m. (Thursday and Friday until 6 p.m., Saturday until 4 p.m.), you have plenty of time to shop and savor a meal.
Beyond food, the market offers a variety of unique finds, from artisanal soaps at Kettlemade Soaps to the lovely seasonal arrangements at Novita’s Flowers and Gifts. Whether you’re treating yourself or searching for a thoughtful gift, there’s something here for everyone, making it a quintessential shopping destination.
Community feedback highlights the market’s charm and quality. Visitors on platforms like Yelp and Tripadvisor share their love for the freshness of the products, noting it as “the epicenter of Amish goodness” and a spot with an “endless supply” of meats and produce. While not every experience is perfect—there can be a less-than-stellar lemon or an underwhelming buffet—the general consensus affirms that the Mullica Hill Amish Market is a South Jersey gem not to be missed. Ample parking and friendly staff add to the welcoming atmosphere, making every visit a joy.
If you're in the Mullica Hill area—or even if you're not—make a point to visit this wonderful market. Discover farm-fresh offerings, support small vendors, and enjoy a slice of tradition. Grab a donut, indulge in some crab cakes, and see why this market holds a special place in the hearts of so many. You might just find yourself planning your next trip back before you’ve even left!